But don't you think it's a little out of line to strike someone with an illness and not tell them what sin they have to repent of in order to be healed?

Thats a perfect example of why I reject revealed God theology, whether people try to apply it to kidney stones or to Katrina.

Care to explain how this saving from sin is suppose to work without going into the xian understanding of jc?

How it works remains to be explored, if need be. That it happens seems pretty clear from our most recent exchanges.

Xian understanding? JC who? Ive sought all along, on this thread, to avoid all such references. I dont anticipate changing my tune.

P.