ok, you actually can use my revised version, but you would have to change the magic question, and it would have to be 2 questions instead of just one. The first question would be "according to the original holy scriptures, what is the way to atonement?", or with any number of similar variations. The second question would be "All dogs are mammals. All cats are mammals. Therefore all cats are dogs. True or false?"

Then you accept the answer from the group that answers false to the second question.