mark wrote:
But when you start to have those experiences personally, and it's no longer hearsay, and you know darn well you've never used LSD, etc., then maybe it's wise to pay attention.  After all, G-d used supernatural experiences to convince many people in the Bible that He was real, and that their beliefs - or lack thereof - needed... adjusting.
I can't help but wonder how you, Mark, would have reacted to Pharaoh's magicians duplicating Moses' turning a staff into a snake?   Every religion can point to supernatural experiences -- do you think that parents sacrificed their children in fire to the "god" Moloch without supernatural experiences??
“How long will you waver between two opinions? If the L-rd is G-d, follow him; but if Baal is god, follow him.”  1 King 18:21
They surely believed in Baal with all their hearts.  They had supernatural experiences.  So why aren't you and Michael Brown worshiping Baal? 

Mohammed regularly went into a state of trance (wahi) and heard a voice dictating All-h's own words.  If all it takes is for you to believe in supernatural experiences why aren't you a Muslim?

Joseph Smith received a supernatural visit where G-d dictated the Book of Mormon to him which he wrote on golden plates (which conveniently no one else ever saw).  Why aren't you a Mormon?  Link to Baptist Minister who became a Mormon after a "supernatural experience."

You are ignoring these "supernatural experiences" while trying to convince Jews that yours is special. 

It isn't

Idolatry has always been attractive -- and it has always been forbidden, too.  Read, re-read and re-read again D'varim / Deuteronomy chapters 4 and 13.

סופי

And everything that Sarah tells you, listen to her voice. Bereshit (Genesis) 21:12