Dougg,
So were Thaddaeus, Matthew or Bartholomew disciples or were they replaced by Nathaniel, Joseph of Arimathea and Judas son of Simon (or son of James)?

How many were present when the risen jc appeared to them?
10 - John20:24
11- (Judas was dead) Matthew 28:16, Mark 16:14, Luke 24:23
12- (Even though Judas was dead) Matthew 27:5, Acts 1:18, Corinthians 15:5

Where did this take place?
Jerusalem - Luke 24:13-53 or
Galilee - Matthew 28:7-20

They recieved the hs when?
The first Easter Sunday- John 20:22
On Pentecost, 50 days later Acts 1:5,8 2:1-4

100% ????????