Yuku free message boards

The claim that Jsus came precisely when the prophets said he "had to arrive" is bull *@! R' Moshe Shulman debunked this claim of Brown's in two articles you can find on his website and at this thread: Rabbi Shulman's reponse to Dr Brown's dating

Brown even admitted that he was wrong about his dating! I wonder if the video you viewed was made before or AFTER Brown admitted he erred? Read the thread and follow the thread to R' Shulman's website.

Then you asked if Jsus was a prophet. If Jsus ever lived he never made one prophecy that came true. Not one.

Take the "prophecy" of the 2nd Temple's destruction -- IF Jsus made such a prophecy (hard to say since the GT was written after the Temple was gone) he got it wrong. This so called prophecy is more proof that Jsus was a false prophet (if he ever lived at all).

You give me the opportunity to replay one of my favorite posts. Lets review the GT -- it speaks of multiple buildings. It speaks of "not one stone." And in Luke it clearly states that he is speaking of JERUSALEM, not just the Temple:

Quote:

---

Matthew 24:2
"Do you see all these things?" he asked. "I tell you the truth, not one stone here will be left on another; every one will be thrown down."

Mark 13: 1 As he was leaving the temple, one of his disciples said to him, "Look, Teacher! What massive stones! What magnificent buildings!" 2"Do you see all these great buildings?" replied J-sus. "Not one stone here will be left on another; every one will be thrown down."

Luke 19: 41 As he approached Jerusalem and saw the city, he wept over it 42 and said. . .They will not leave one stone on another, because you did not recognize the time of G-d's coming to you."

---

When Jerusalem was destroyed a historian of the period wrote that parts of it were left standing:

Quote:

---

Caesar gave orders that they should. . . leave as many of the towers standing as were of the greatest eminence; that is, Phasaelus, and Hippicus, and Mariamne; and so much of the wall as enclosed the city on the west side. This wall was spared. . .Titus Flavius

---

And what remains even today of Herods Temple and Jerusalem that proves J-sus to be a false prophet?

In 1968 the ground in front of the Wall was excavated to reveal two of the buried rows of stone, and the Wall then consisted of seven layers of huge, marginally dressed ("Herodian") stones from the Second Temple. . .

The Western Wall Tunnel 320 meters (1,050 ft.), originally explored by two British archaeologists: Charles Wilson, in 1864, and Charles Warren, in 1867-1870. The two archaeologists found that the Wall continued approximately 320 meters (1,050 ft.) and that some structures still existed from the Temple period.

An aqueduct Found near the northern part of the Wall, the aqueduct was used during the time of the Maccabbees, about 150 BCE.

There is also a hall near Wilsons Arch that that is part of a group of buildings from the Second Temple era, which are located next to the Temple Mount.

Here is a picture for you:



We have historical proof from the Romans (let alone the actual stones themselves).

Even had Jsus only been speaking of the Temple and not all of Jerusalem, the facts show him to be a false prophet:

Quote:

---

In 1968 the ground in front of the Wall was excavated to reveal two of the buried rows of stone, and the Wall then consisted of seven layers of huge, marginally dressed ("Herodian" stones from the Second Temple. . .

The Western Wall Tunnel 320 meters (1,050 ft.), originally explored by two British archaeologists: Charles Wilson, in 1864, and Charles Warren, in 1867-1870. The two archaeologists found that the Wall continued approximately 320 meters (1,050 ft.) and that some structures still existed from the Temple period.

An aqueduct Found near the northern part of the Wall, the aqueduct was used during the time of the Maccabbees, about 150 BCE.

There is also a hall near Wilsons Arch that that is part of a group of buildings from the Second Temple era, which are located next to the Temple Mount.

Then there is a Mikveh, which was supplied with water from an subterranean spring. Some feel the presence of the Mikveh indicates that the room may have been used by the Cohanim as part of their performace of the Temple service. Here is a picture for you

---

Dont forget the massive arch originally constructed by Herod and now known after a British explorer in the 1860s.

Here is a picture of the largest stone in the Temple Wall tunnel



Here is a picture of the western flight of stairs leading to the main entrances of the Temple



See what I mean? False prophet. This is just one of many examples. Jsus also said he was coming back within the life span of his followers "not one would taste death." They've all been dead about 1980 years or so. Nope not even ONE of his "prophecies" came to pass.

Not to mention that the age of prophecy had been over for hundreds of years!
http://www.judaismsanswer.com/ResponseDrBrown.htm) Now this sounds convincing. We should certainly expect a scholar of the caliber of Dr. Brown to be...">